🇺🇸 Made in America·100% U.S.-Based Team · 24+ Years in Cost Segregation
📞 1-888-365-5023info@costsegamerica.com
Home/The Strategy Room/Depreciation Recapture
The Objection That Costs Investors Millions

"But You’ll Have to Pay It Back When You Sell."
And It is Still Worth It.

The investor who understands recapture moves forward. The one who doesn’t stalls — and leaves capital on the table while the analysis never gets done.

Depreciation recapture is the single most common reason investors hesitate. Most of the time, that hesitation costs more than the recapture would. This page explains why — with the math, not the marketing.

Run the Numbers on My Building →Call 1-888-365-5023
Time Value Works in Your Favor
12% Permanent Rate Differential on 15-Yr
4 Strategies to Reduce Recapture
125+ Audits Defended
Zero Losses
The Math — Side by Side

Same Property. Same Sale. Two Completely Different Outcomes.

The #1 objection to cost segregation is recapture. "Won't I just have to pay it all back when I sell?" The answer is no — and the math proves it. Column A took cost segregation and paid full recapture at sale. Column B took no cost segregation and paid no recapture. Column A still wins by $13,292. And that does not include the time value of the money collected years earlier.

Shared assumptions — both columns identical
Purchase price: $2,000,000
Land value: $200,000 (10%)
Depreciable basis: $1,800,000
Sale price: $2,500,000
Years held: 5 years
Tax bracket: 37% ordinary income
LTCG rate: 20% + 3.8% NIIT = 23.8%
§1250 recapture rate: 25% maximum
Col A reclassification: 30% ($540,000)
Line item
Column A
With Cost Segregation
Column B
No Cost Segregation
During Ownership — 5 Years
Total depreciation taken
Over the 5-year hold period
$701,538
$540,000 bonus + $161,538 SL
$230,769
$46,154 × 5 years
Tax savings during hold
Depreciation × 37% ordinary rate
$259,569
Including $199,800 in Year 1 alone
$85,385
$17,077 per year × 5 years
At Sale — Year 5
Total taxable gain on sale
Sale price $2,500,000 − adjusted basis
$1,201,538
$730,769
§1245 recapture (ord income)
5-yr personal property depreciation
$360,000
Taxed at 37% ordinary income rate
$0
No 5-yr property — no §1245 recapture
Unrecaptured §1250 gain
All real property depreciation taken
$341,538
Taxed at 25% maximum rate
$230,769
Taxed at 25% maximum rate
Total tax at sale
All recapture + LTCG taxes combined
$337,585
$160,892 more than Column B
$176,692
Lower sale tax — but higher total cost
True Net Position — Complete Picture
True Net Position
Column A — With Cost Seg
$2,421,985
$13,293 ahead of Column B
Column B — No Cost Seg
$2,408,692
$13,293 behind Column A
The Recapture Objection — Dissolved
Column A paid $160,892 more in recapture. Column A still won by $13,293.
The owner in Column A collected $259,569 in tax savings during the hold period — $174,185 more than Column B. Even after paying $160,892 more in recapture at sale, they came out ahead. Recapture does not eliminate the advantage. It reduces it. The math always works.
Extra recapture tax paid
$160,892
Extra savings collected
$174,185
Net advantage — Col A
$13,293
The number above understates the real advantage
Column A received $199,800 in Year 1 from the bonus depreciation deduction. Column B received $17,077 per year for five years. A dollar in hand in Year 1 is worth more than a dollar received in Year 5 — at any positive discount rate. The time value of money makes Column A's advantage materially larger than $13,293 when properly accounted for.
"If I take all this depreciation now, won't I just have to pay it all back when I sell?"
No — and the math above is the proof. Recapture means you pay tax on the depreciation you took, at rates between 25% and 37% depending on property type. But you already received those deductions at your full ordinary income rate of 37%. The tax you collected at 37% is larger than the recapture you pay at 25%–37%. The spread between what you collected and what you repay is your permanent, after-tax advantage — and it exists regardless of whether you ever sell. If you hold the property until death, a stepped-up basis eliminates the recapture entirely. If you do a 1031 exchange, the recapture is deferred indefinitely. If you sell outright — as this example shows — you still come out ahead.
Run the Numbers on Your Property

Every Property Has Its Own Math. Let's Build Yours.

A free Cost Seg America proposal tells you exactly what your building qualifies for — deductions, recapture at sale, net after-tax position — before you commit to anything.

Get Free Proposal →Call 1-888-365-5023
The Complete Recapture Analysis

The Math on Your Building. Not a Sales Pitch. The Numbers.

We will walk through the recapture analysis on your specific property with your specific holding period and tax situation. Free. 24-hour response. If we cannot find more in deductions than our fee — you owe us nothing.

$48,000+
Permanent benefit from time value alone on a $2M property — even at the same tax rate
Run the Numbers on My Building →Call 1-888-365-5023