Yes, you can turn down bonus depreciation, and sometimes you should. Section 168(k)(7) of the tax code lets you elect out of bonus depreciation for an entire class of property for a tax year. A cost segregation study still sorts your building into land, the long-life structure and the shorter-life property. The election only changes how fast the shorter-life property is deducted. With bonus, it is deducted in the first year. Without bonus, it is deducted over 5 years or 15 years on the regular schedules, which is still far faster than 27.5 or 39 years.
Most owners should take the bonus. A deduction this year is usually worth more than the same deduction later. But there is one situation where taking it all now costs real money: a year when your income is unusually low and you expect it to jump. In that year, a huge deduction lands against income taxed at 0, 10 and 12 percent. The same dollars, spread into later years, would have offset income taxed at 24 or 32 percent.
Below we walk through a couple who saved about $15,000 over six years by electing out, a high earner who would have lost about $54,000 in year one by doing the same thing, and the rules your CPA follows to make the election. Everything here is federal tax only. It is general education, not advice for your return, and your CPA makes the final call.
Mateo and Ana Reyes are illustrative owners we built to show the math. Their numbers are realistic. They are not client results.
Mateo is in the last year of a cardiology fellowship in Denver. He works brutal hours and earns $85,000. Ana teaches high school part time and earns $40,000. In January 2027, Mateo starts as an attending physician. His offer letter says $440,000. Their household income is about to go from $125,000 to $480,000.
They did not wait. In June 2026 they bought a four-bedroom cabin outside Breckenridge for $900,000 and opened it to guests the same month. The average stay that summer was four nights. Ana runs it. She answers every guest message, sets the prices, orders the supplies and meets the plumber. Her log shows 310 hours by December. The cleaner worked 150. Because the average stay is seven days or less and Ana materially participates, the cabin is not treated as a rental activity under the passive loss rules. Its loss is nonpassive, and it can offset their wages.
Their CPA ordered a cost segregation study. It came back with a first-year deduction of about $201,700. Ana did the math on a napkin. Their income for the year was $125,000 in wages plus $30,000 from the cabin. The deduction was bigger than everything they earned.
"That's great," Mateo said. "We pay zero."
"We pay zero this year," Ana said. "This is the cheapest tax year we will ever have."
She was right. And she had just asked the question that most owners never hear asked.
Start with the basics. When you buy a rental, the tax code makes you deduct the building a little at a time. A long-term residential rental runs 27.5 years. A commercial building, or a short-term rental where the average stay is 30 days or less, runs 39 years. Land never depreciates at all.
A cost segregation study is a component-by-component analysis of what you bought. It separates the parts that are not the structure, such as certain flooring, dedicated electrical, appliances and specialty lighting, which generally run on a 5-year schedule. It separates the site work, such as driveways, parking, walkways, fencing, landscaping and exterior lighting, which generally runs on a 15-year schedule. Everything else stays with the building.
Bonus depreciation is a separate rule. It lets you deduct qualifying property with a recovery period of 20 years or less all at once, in the year it is placed in service. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, made 100 percent bonus depreciation permanent for qualifying property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025. Our guide to 100 percent bonus depreciation covers the details.
Bonus is automatic. If you do nothing, it applies. Section 168(k)(7) gives you the right to say no. When you elect out for a class of property, that class goes back to its regular schedule. The 5-year property is deducted over six tax years, starting at 20 percent in year one and 32 percent in year two. The 15-year property is deducted over 16 tax years, starting at 5 percent and then 9.5 percent. Those are the standard IRS table rates under the half-year convention.
Two things never change. The total depreciation you can claim over the life of the property is the same either way. You can never deduct more than you paid. And the cost segregation study is just as valuable either way, because it is the study that moves those dollars off the 27.5-year or 39-year schedule in the first place. The election only decides which years receive them.
A deduction is not worth a fixed amount. It is worth whatever tax it removes. That depends on which bracket the deduction lands in.
For a married couple filing jointly in 2026, the first $32,200 of income is covered by the standard deduction and taxed at zero. The next $24,800 of taxable income is taxed at 10 percent. Income up to $100,800 is taxed at 12 percent. Then 22 percent up to $211,400, 24 percent up to $403,550, and 32 percent up to $512,450. These thresholds are adjusted annually.
Look at what that means for Mateo and Ana. In 2026, the first dollars of their deduction remove income taxed at 22 percent, then 12 percent, then 10 percent, then zero. In 2027 and every year after, a dollar of deduction removes income taxed at 32 percent or 24 percent.
A deduction that wipes out a low-income year is a deduction spent at a discount. Any part of it that goes beyond zero does not vanish. It becomes a net operating loss that carries forward. But a net operating loss arising after 2020 can only offset 80 percent of taxable income in a later year, and it has already burned through the zero, 10 and 12 percent brackets on the way down. That is the trap.
Here are the facts. Every figure is illustrative and rounded. We use the 2026 brackets for every year to keep the comparison clean.
First-year depreciation is $194,400 of bonus plus $7,311 on the building, for $201,711. Their income before depreciation is $155,000. Their adjusted gross income falls to negative $46,711. They owe no federal income tax for 2026, and they carry a net operating loss of about $46,700 into 2027.
From 2027 on, the only depreciation left is the building, about $13,476 a year. The 5-year and 15-year property is used up.
First-year depreciation is 20 percent of $120,000, which is $24,000, plus 5 percent of $74,400, which is $3,720, plus the same $7,311 on the building. That totals $35,031. Their adjusted gross income is $119,969. After the standard deduction, taxable income is $87,769 and federal income tax is about $10,036.
In 2027, depreciation is $58,944: $38,400 on the 5-year property, $7,068 on the 15-year property and $13,476 on the building. In 2028 it is $42,878. The deductions taper over the next several years instead of disappearing after year one.
| Federal income tax | No study | Study with bonus | Study, bonus elected out |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 depreciation | $10,015 | $201,711 | $35,031 |
| 2026 tax | $14,237 | $0 | $10,036 |
| 2027 tax | $109,501 | $96,148 | $96,546 |
| 2028 tax | $109,501 | $111,096 | $101,687 |
| Total, 2026 through 2031 | $561,742 | $540,532 | $525,530 |
| Saved compared with no study | $21,210 | $36,212 |
Read the bottom row twice. The study is worth money either way. With bonus, it saves about $21,200 over six years. With bonus elected out, it saves about $36,200. Electing out puts about $15,000 more in their pocket over the same six years, and it still leaves 15-year deductions on the schedule for the years after 2031. Discounted at 5 percent a year, the gap is still about $15,300 in favor of electing out.
Why? Because with bonus, roughly $166,700 of extra deduction landed in 2026, where it removed income taxed at 12 percent and below, or turned into a carryforward. Without bonus, those same dollars arrive in 2027 through 2031, where they remove income taxed at 24 and 32 percent.
Yes, they write a check for about $10,000 in April 2027 that they could have avoided. That is the trade. Ten thousand dollars now buys about $25,000 of savings over the next five years. Ana took the trade.
Gloria Whitfield, another illustrative owner, is an anesthesiologist in Scottsdale. She files jointly, and her household earns $600,000 a year in wages. She expects to earn about the same for the next decade. She buys the same cabin on the same day, with the same study.
With bonus, her 2026 taxable income is about $396,100 and her federal income tax is about $80,300. If she elected out, taxable income would be about $562,800 and tax about $134,500. Taking the bonus saves her about $54,250 in year one.
Gloria's income is high this year and high every year after. A dollar of deduction removes income taxed at 24 to 35 percent whether it arrives now or in 2029. When the rate is the same, the earlier deduction wins, because money you keep today can pay down the mortgage, fund the next property or sit in the bank earning interest. For Gloria, electing out would be a gift to the IRS.
This is why the answer is never "always take the bonus" or "always elect out." The answer is in your next five years of income, not in the building.
Most owners will never need the election. These are the situations where your CPA should at least run it both ways.
If your rental loss is passive and you have no passive income to absorb it, the loss is suspended either way. It carries forward until you have passive income or sell your entire interest in a fully taxable sale to an unrelated buyer. Electing out changes the timing of a loss you cannot use yet, and it rarely changes the outcome. Our post on suspended passive losses covers the release rules.
If you are already in a high bracket and expect to stay there, keep the bonus. That is Gloria.
And if you expect to retire or slow down in a few years, you have the opposite of Mateo and Ana's problem. Your rate is higher now than it will be later, which argues for taking every dollar of deduction now.
The election has rules, and they are less flexible than most owners assume.
It is made by class, not by building. You elect out for a class of property, such as all 5-year property or all 15-year property, for a tax year. The election applies to every asset in that class that you placed in service that year. If you placed two buildings in service in 2026 and elect out of the 15-year class, the parking lot at the second building goes with it. You cannot keep bonus on one property and drop it on another in the same class and year.
You can split the classes. You can elect out of the 5-year class and keep bonus on the 15-year class, or the reverse. In Mateo and Ana's case, electing out of only the 5-year class and keeping bonus on the 15-year class still cut their 2026 tax to about $1,700 and landed within about $1,000 of the full election over six years. For some owners, a split is the best of both.
It is made on a timely filed return, including extensions. The CPA attaches a statement to the return identifying the class of property. That means you do not have to decide in December. You can decide in March or September, when you know what the year actually looked like. Most owners never hear that.
It is hard to undo. Once made, the election generally cannot be revoked without IRS consent. There is a narrow window to change course on an amended return after a timely filed original, and your CPA confirms whether it applies. Treat the decision as final.
Partnerships and S corporations make it at the entity level. If the property sits in a partnership or an S corporation, the entity makes the election, not each owner. Every owner gets the same answer. If the owners are in very different tax situations, that is a conversation to have before the return is filed.
It does not change the land, the building or the study. The study still separates land, which never depreciates. The building still runs on its long schedule. The election only touches the classes you name.
Watch the fourth quarter. If more than 40 percent of the depreciable property other than buildings that you place in service during the year goes into service in the last three months, a mid-quarter convention replaces the half-year convention, and the first-year rates shrink. With bonus, that rarely matters. Without bonus, it does. Our post on what placed in service means explains how the date is set.
One more case where the election shows up: owners withdrawing an old real property interest election under Rev. Proc. 2026-17 can make a late election out of bonus in the withdrawal year. Our post on withdrawing a 163(j) election explains when that helps.
Take these to your CPA. Bring the study report.
That last question is the one that settles it. A CPA with a proper component schedule can run all three versions in an afternoon. A CPA with a single percentage from a cheap estimate cannot, because there are no classes to split.
The QBI deduction. If your rental counts as a trade or business, depreciation lowers the qualified business income that the 20 percent deduction under Section 199A is calculated on. A big first-year deduction can shrink that deduction in year one. Our post on cost segregation and the QBI deduction walks through the arithmetic.
Material participation. The whole reason Mateo and Ana can use the loss against wages is Ana's log. If her hours fell short, the loss would be passive, and the election question would mostly disappear. Our guide on proving material participation shows what a defensible log looks like, and our short-term rental guide explains the seven-day rule. Long-term landlords should read our post on real estate professional status.
The sale. Depreciation lowers your basis whether you take it with bonus or without. When you sell, gain on the 5-year property is generally taxed as ordinary income up to the depreciation taken. Gain tied to the building's straight-line depreciation is generally taxed at up to 25 percent. The 15-year site work follows its own rules, and accelerated depreciation on it can be taxed as ordinary income. Electing out does not avoid any of that. It changes the years the deductions arrive, not the fact that they were taken. Our guide to depreciation recapture covers the full picture.
When you take 100 percent bonus, every reclassified dollar is deducted at once, and the split between 5-year and 15-year property does not change the first-year deduction. When you elect out of one class and keep the other, the split decides real dollars every year for 16 years. It has to be right.
Cost Seg America performs studies under IRS Approach 1 and Approach 2 only, the two methods the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide describes as building from actual cost records and from detailed engineering estimates reconciled to the price you paid. No modeling software fills the gaps. Our analysts review your property component by component. On larger properties that means an in-house analyst on site. On others it means a tele-engineering review over live video, or precise photo and video instructions that our team reviews. All engineering is done in the USA.
You get a component schedule that lists each item, its cost and its class. Your CPA uses it to run the return with bonus, without bonus and with a split. An examiner can trace every line back to your purchase price. That is what Engineered, Not Estimated means.
Studies are delivered in 20 business days, and rush studies are available. You talk directly with the analyst working on your study. Every study carries lifetime audit defense with no cap and no fee, and the team behind our studies has defended 125+ IRS audits with zero losses. We typically find $200,000 to $450,000 in additional first-year federal deductions per $1 million of property value. If you bought in an earlier year and never claimed it, the IRS allows you to go back and claim deductions you never took through a change in accounting method, and Form 3115 support is available for an additional fee. Our post on look-back studies explains how that works.
Our minimum is $180,000 of depreciable basis after land is taken out. Below that, the fee tends to outweigh the benefit. A study may also not fit if you plan to sell within a couple of years without an exchange, because recapture arrives before the timing benefit has done much. If your loss will be passive for years with no passive income in sight, the deduction waits, and you may choose to wait too. We will tell you plainly when a study does not fit. Our post on when not to do cost segregation goes through the numbers.
Yes. Section 168(k)(7) lets you elect out of bonus depreciation for any class of property for a tax year. The election covers all property in that class placed in service that year, and your CPA makes it with a statement attached to a timely filed return, including extensions.
Because a deduction is worth the tax it removes. In a year when your income is unusually low, a large deduction removes income taxed at low rates or creates a loss that carries forward. If your income is about to rise sharply, spreading the deduction into those higher years can save more tax overall.
Yes. Without a study, the property sits on a 27.5-year or 39-year schedule. With a study and no bonus, the reclassified property is deducted over 5 and 15 years, which is still far faster. In our example, the study saved about $36,200 over six years with bonus elected out.
Not within the same class and the same year. The election applies to every asset in the class placed in service that year. You can elect out of one class, such as 5-year property, and keep bonus on another, such as 15-year property.
By the due date of the return for the year the property was placed in service, including extensions. You can make the decision after the year ends, with your real income in front of you.
Generally not without IRS consent. There is a narrow window to change it on an amended return after a timely original filing, and your CPA confirms whether it applies. Plan as if the decision is final.
If the loss is nonpassive, the part that exceeds your income generally becomes a net operating loss that carries forward. In later years it can offset up to 80 percent of taxable income. Losses above the excess business loss cap also carry forward as a net operating loss.
Only to the extent you have taken less depreciation by the time you sell. Recapture is based on depreciation allowed or allowable, so skipping deductions does not avoid it. Plan the study, the election and the sale together.
The partnership or S corporation makes it, not the individual owners. Every owner gets the same treatment.
In February, Ana sat down with their CPA and the study report. The CPA ran the return three ways: full bonus, no bonus and a split. The numbers matched the napkin. They elected out of bonus for both classes, wrote a check for about $10,000 in April and kept every dollar of 5-year and 15-year depreciation waiting for the years Mateo's new salary would be taxed at 24 and 32 percent.
Mateo had one comment. "I spent five years learning to read an EKG. I never thought to read my own tax brackets."
Gloria took the bonus and never thought about it again. Both of them were right, because both of them asked the question before the return was filed.
You can start now. If you own a rental, a short-term rental or a commercial building, or you are about to buy one, send Jim Dougherty and his team the address, the purchase price, the closing date and the date the property was ready for use. You will receive a proposal the same day or the next morning showing the projected first-year deduction and the fee, and a plain answer on whether a study makes sense for you. We work directly with your CPA, and we do the heavy lifting. Call 1-888-365-5023 or email info@costsegamerica.com.
Jim Dougherty and his team
This article is general education about federal tax rules and is not tax or legal advice. The examples are illustrative, the figures are rounded, the brackets used are for 2026 and are adjusted annually, and every situation depends on its own facts. Talk to your CPA about your own situation before making any decision.
Use the calculator, see your number, and request your free, no-cost proposal - delivered in 24 hours, with your flat fee quoted upfront and no obligation.