The grouping election lets you treat two or more activities as one activity for the passive loss rules, so your participation is measured across the group instead of building by building. For an owner who rents a building to their own business, grouping the building with the business is what turns a cost segregation loss from a stranded passive carryforward into a deduction against business income this year. The catch comes first: grouping is hard to undo, it changes how suspended losses are released when you sell one piece, and it cannot turn an ordinary rental into a nonpassive activity for someone whose day job is something else. It is your CPA's election to make. Your job is to recognize the pattern and raise it before the study is ordered.
Otis Hart is a dentist in Evansville, Indiana. In March 2025 he bought the building his practice had been renting for nine years, a single-story medical office on Lincoln Avenue, for $1,400,000. He put it in its own LLC and the practice pays the LLC rent. He also owns three small rentals across town.
He did what a careful owner does. He ordered a fully engineered and accounted cost segregation study on the practice building, and it supported a first-year deduction large enough to wipe out the building's rental income and produce a loss of about $324,000. He expected that loss to offset his practice income. His CPA at the time told his it could not.
He was right, as far as he went. Because the practice pays rent to a building Otis owns, the self-rental rule applies: net income from that building is treated as nonpassive, but a net loss stays passive. His three rentals barely broke even, so there was no passive income to absorb it. The largest deduction he owned went into a suspended passive loss carryforward and sat there.
His new CPA looked at the file for about ten minutes and said one word. "Grouping." He filed the grouping statement with his 2025 return, and the loss offset his practice income.
The regulations let an owner group a rental with a business he owns when the two have the same ownership. Grouped with the practice, the building became part of the business Otis materially participates in every working day. Measured as part of the practice instead of alone, the loss offset practice income. The stranded loss came loose.
The tax code treats rental real estate as passive by default. Passive losses offset passive income and nothing else. A cost segregation study produces a large loss in year one, and if that loss is passive and you have no passive income, it carries forward and waits.
There are ways out of the passive box: real estate professional status, the short-term rental carve-out, material participation in a business. Every one of those tests is applied to an activity. By default, each rental can be its own activity, and a building you rent to your own business is a rental activity sitting alone. Your participation in the business does not count toward the building because the building is measured by itself.
That was Otis's trap. He spends fifty hours a week in that building. None of them counted, because the building was a separate activity from the practice.
Reg. 1.469-4 lets a taxpayer treat one or more trade or business activities and rental activities as a single activity when they form an appropriate economic unit. Similar types of business, common control, common ownership, location and interdependence all bear on that.
Rentals get a stricter rule under Reg. 1.469-4(d)(1)(ii). A rental activity can be grouped with a trade or business activity only if the rental is insubstantial next to the business, the business is insubstantial next to the rental, or each owner of the business has the same proportionate interest in the rental. Otis owns 100 percent of the practice and 100 percent of the building LLC, so the ownership test is met.
Once grouped, the participation tests apply to the whole activity. Otis's 2,000 hours in the practice are hours in the grouped activity, which includes the building. The grouped activity is nonpassive. The building's loss is a loss inside it.
His three other rentals stayed passive. Grouping cannot make an ordinary rental nonpassive for someone whose day job is dentistry; only real estate professional status does that, and Otis does not qualify. But the practice building carried the largest study by far, and that is the one grouping reached.
These figures are illustrative and simplified to show the mechanics.
Purchase price $1,400,000. Land, allocated at $250,000, comes out first. Depreciable basis $1,150,000. Placed in service March 2025, so the building takes the IRS mid-month table rate for March, 2.033 percent, in year one. The building's 2025 net income before depreciation, rent from the practice less interest, taxes and insurance, is $60,000.
Without a study:
With a fully engineered and accounted study that supports 32 percent reclassification, which is the high end of the range and typical for medical and dental office because of the plumbing, gas and dedicated electrical that serve operatory equipment:
Ungrouped, that $323,898 is a passive loss. His rentals produce no passive income. It is suspended and carries forward, worth nothing this year.
Grouped with the practice, the $323,898 is a loss inside a nonpassive activity. Otis files jointly with his wife, so the Section 461(l) excess business loss cap of $626,000 for 2025, adjusted annually, sits well above it. At a 37 percent federal rate the loss is worth $119,842 of federal tax on their 2025 return. That is the value of one word, and it is the cost of every year a loss like this sits frozen.
Otis's situation is the most common version of the pattern. It fits anyone who owns the real estate their own business operates from and holds it in a separate entity: the contractor who owns the shop and yard his company rents, the physician group whose partners own the clinic building in the same percentages they own the practice, the restaurant owner who bought the building, the owner of a machine shop or a veterinary clinic. In every one of those cases the self-rental rule makes the building's income nonpassive and its loss passive, and in every one of them a cost segregation study produces a loss in year one.
The ownership test is where the pattern breaks. If three physicians own the practice in equal thirds but only two of them own the building, the proportionate ownership test fails and the rental cannot be grouped with the practice on that ground alone. If the building is owned by a spouse who is not in the business, same problem. Some of those structures can be fixed, and the fix has to be in place before the grouping year. The time to look at the ownership chart is before the building is bought, and the second-best time is before the study is ordered.
Put a number on waiting. Otis's loss was $323,898. Frozen for one year as a passive carryforward and used the next, the cost is the time value of $119,842 of tax for twelve months, which at the rate he pays on his practice line of credit is roughly $9,500 of interest he would not have needed to pay. Frozen for five years, because his rentals never produce passive income and nobody raises grouping, the cost is closer to $50,000 plus the risk that his income in the eventual year of release is lower and the deduction is worth less. The deduction survives the wait and shrinks in value every year of it, and grouping is what stops the waiting.
People say "grouping election" to mean several different moves, and they work differently.
There is the general grouping of activities into appropriate economic units under Reg. 1.469-4, which is what Otis used. There is the narrower rule inside it for grouping a rental with a business. And there is a separate aggregation election under Section 469(c)(7)(A), available only to taxpayers who qualify as real estate professionals, that treats all of their rental real estate as a single activity for the material participation test. That election is what lets a real estate professional with eight rentals count hours across all eight. It does nothing for a dentist.
The mechanisms are distinct, the requirements are specific, and the paperwork is specific. Under Rev. Proc. 2010-13, a new grouping has to be disclosed in a written statement filed with the original return for the first year it applies, naming the activities grouped. Miss the disclosure and the grouping may not hold. That is why this is a CPA's job.
Once activities are grouped, you cannot regroup them whenever it suits you. A grouping is meant to be consistent from year to year and can be changed only if the original grouping was clearly inappropriate or there has been a material change in facts. There is no annual switch.
That matters because grouping that helps now can hurt later. Suspended passive losses are released in full when you dispose of your entire interest in the activity in a fully taxable sale. If the activity is a group, selling one building is not a disposition of the activity, and the losses stay suspended. An owner who groups five rentals, then sells one with a big suspended loss attached, does not get that loss released at the sale. For Otis, grouping the building with the practice means that if he someday sells the building but keeps practicing, the activity continues and any suspended losses stay put.
So the election is a decision with downstream consequences: your participation, your portfolio, your plans to buy and sell, your other income. The right answer for Otis could be the wrong answer for someone with an identical-looking portfolio and different plans.
Grouping decides whether the loss is usable. The study decides whether the loss survives a question. An estimated study, a percentage applied to the purchase price from a database of other buildings, gives Otis a number and nothing underneath it: no component list, no cost records, nothing an examiner can trace. That is Approach 6 territory in the IRS Audit Techniques Guide, which the guide describes as having little or no documentation and tells examiners to view with caution. A $324,000 loss against business income deserves a better foundation than that.
A fully engineered and accounted study examines the building component by component under Approaches 1 and 2 of the guide, from actual cost records where they exist and documented estimates reconciled to the purchase price where they do not. It delivers a component schedule with each asset's cost, class and recovery period that his CPA imports and an examiner can trace line by line. It is signed by the credentialed professionals who prepared it, and Cost Seg America defends it for as long as he owns the building, with no time limit, no hour cap and no additional fee, with written responses and participation in examiner calls alongside his CPA. The grouping statement and the component schedule go in the same file, and together they answer both questions an examiner would ask.
Treating grouping as a do-it-yourself move. The tests are specific, the disclosure statement is mandatory, and the consequences last. Your CPA executes it.
Assuming grouping is always favorable. It can lock suspended losses inside a group when you sell one piece. Weigh the exit before you group.
Confusing general grouping with the real estate professional aggregation election. One is for appropriate economic units and can join a rental to a business. The other is only for qualifying real estate professionals and only joins rentals to rentals.
Expecting grouping to fix an ordinary rental. A rental with no business to join stays passive no matter how many hours you put in, unless you are a real estate professional or it is a short-term rental you materially participate in.
Building the loss first and asking about usability after. Otis came within one CPA of losing a year. Raise grouping with your CPA when the study is proposed.
If you do not own a business the rental can join, grouping does not apply to you and the passive question has to be answered another way. If the building has under $180,000 of depreciable basis after land, the study fee eats the benefit regardless of grouping. If you plan to sell the building within a couple of years, the 5-year and 15-year deductions come back as ordinary-income recapture under Section 1245 and the time value usually does not cover it. And if you have other suspended losses you are counting on releasing at a sale, grouping can trap them; that trade-off is sometimes the reason not to group.
A choice under Reg. 1.469-4 to treat two or more activities as one for the passive loss rules, when they form an appropriate economic unit. Your participation is then measured across the group instead of activity by activity.
Only if the rental is insubstantial next to the business, the business is insubstantial next to the rental, or every owner of the business holds the same proportionate interest in the rental. An owner who holds 100 percent of both meets the last test.
Because of the self-rental rule. Net income from property rented to a business you materially participate in is treated as nonpassive. A net loss from the same property stays passive. Grouping the building with the business is how most owners resolve that.
No. The aggregation election under Section 469(c)(7)(A) is only for qualifying real estate professionals and only combines rental real estate for the material participation test. General grouping is available to anyone with activities that form an economic unit.
No. Without a business to join and without real estate professional status, a rental stays passive. Grouping rentals with each other helps a real estate professional meet material participation; it does not change the passive character for anyone else.
Your CPA files a written disclosure statement with the original return for the first year the grouping applies, naming the activities grouped, under Rev. Proc. 2010-13. There is no form; the statement is the election.
Only if the original grouping was clearly inappropriate or a material change in facts makes it so. Plan on it being permanent.
They stay suspended. Suspended passive losses are released on disposition of your entire interest in the activity, and the activity is the group, not the building.
Decide at the same time. The study sets the size of the loss; the grouping decides whether you can use it this year. Cost Seg America raises the usability question in the proposal conversation so you and your CPA can settle it before the loss exists.
If you rent a building to your own business, or you own several rentals and suspect your losses are stranded, send Jim Dougherty and his team the property address and approximate purchase price. You will have a free proposal in 24 hours showing the projected reclassification, the first-year deduction and the fee, with no obligation, and the proposal conversation is where the usability question gets raised for you and your CPA. The study is delivered in 30 days, rush available. Call 1-888-365-5023 or write to info@costsegamerica.com.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice; consult your CPA about your own situation.
Use the calculator, see your number, and request your free, no-cost proposal - delivered in 24 hours, with your flat fee quoted upfront and no obligation.