🇺🇸 Made in America·100% U.S.-Based Team · 24+ Years in Cost Segregation
Cost Segregation

Why the Depreciation Rules Only Look Like a Secret

Jim Dougherty and team
Jim Dougherty and team
July 23, 2026
•
5 min read

The short answer

There is no secret tax rulebook for the wealthy. The depreciation rules they use on buildings are printed in Section 168 of the Internal Revenue Code, explained in the IRS's own Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide, Publication 5653, and free to anyone with an internet connection. The catch is that reading them is not the same as using them: you need to own a depreciable building, the loss has to be usable under the passive activity rules, and the deduction you accelerate comes back as recapture when you sell. Inside those limits the rules work the same for a retired teacher with one building as for a fund with forty, and what separates them is attention.

Priya at the diner in Chattanooga

Priya taught chemistry at a Chattanooga, Tennessee high school for 31 years. In March 2025, two years into retirement, she bought a 6,000-square-foot commercial building on Brainerd Road for $850,000, with the proceeds from her late husband's lake cabin and a loan from the credit union. A chiropractor rents the front half. A print shop rents the back.

At the diner on Market Street, her nephew, who sells insurance, leaned in and lowered his voice. "The rich guys have loopholes for buildings like that. Stuff regular people never hear about."

Priya had heard that her whole life: hidden tricks and a different rulebook. It is one of the most widely believed and least true ideas in American money, and it nearly cost her $64,000.

What her nephew called a loophole was a 39-year depreciation schedule with a published way to shorten part of it. Priya found that out because the nephew's remark made her curious enough to ask. The arithmetic of what she found is below.

Where the rules live

Everything cost segregation rests on is public.

  • Section 168 of the Internal Revenue Code. It sets the recovery periods: 5, 7 and 15 years for tangible personal property and land improvements, 27.5 for residential rental buildings, 39 for nonresidential buildings. Section 168(k) is bonus depreciation, which the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, restored to 100 percent for property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025.
  • Hospital Corporation of America v. Commissioner, 109 T.C. 21 (1997). The Tax Court held that components of a building can be classified as personal property with their own recovery periods, applying the six questions from Whiteco Industries v. Commissioner, 65 T.C. 664 (1975). Both opinions are online. The six questions, in plain words: can the item be moved, and has it been; is it designed or built to stay in place permanently; do the circumstances show it may have to be moved; how substantial a job is removing it; how much damage does removal do to the item or the building; and how is it attached. An examiner asks the same six questions about every line on a component schedule.
  • Publication 5653, the Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide. Written by the IRS for its own examiners. It describes six common approaches to allocating a building's cost, says which ones are methodical and which have little or no documentation, and lists what an examiner expects to find in a study. Free to download.
  • Form 3115 and the automatic change procedures. The published way to catch up depreciation you should have taken in prior years, on the current return, with no amended returns.

The agency that collects the tax wrote the manual for the deduction. That is the opposite of a secret. It is an invitation printed by the government and ignored by most of the people it would help.

What to read, and how long it takes

You do not need to read the whole manual. You need to read enough to know what you are buying and what an examiner will ask. Here is the list, in order, with the time it took Priya.

DocumentWhat to readWhat you learnTime
Publication 5653, chapter on methodologiesThe descriptions of the six approachesWhich approach your provider uses, and what the guide says about it20 minutes
Publication 5653, chapter on the elements of a quality studyThe list of what a report should containThe questions to ask before you sign15 minutes
Section 168(k)The acquisition and placed-in-service datesWhether your building gets 100 percent bonus10 minutes
Section 469(i)The $25,000 allowance and its phase-outWhether a passive loss helps you this year10 minutes
Hospital Corporation of America, the component discussionThe pages on electrical, plumbing and finishesWhy dedicated systems can be personal property and general systems cannot30 minutes

An hour and a half. Priya did it over two evenings at the same diner. By the end she could ask a provider which approach the study used, whether the report listed components with costs, and whether the Whiteco factors were applied, and she could tell from the answers which quote was an estimate. That advantage, the one people call a secret, cost her two cups of coffee.

Why "loophole" is the wrong word

People reach for the word because it explains why they did not know. A loophole sounds like a flaw somebody clever exploited, which lets you off the hook for not finding it.

A loophole is an accident in the law. Cost segregation is the opposite: Congress wrote shorter recovery periods into the statute on purpose, to reward investment in buildings and equipment, and the IRS wrote a guide describing how it reviews the work. Nobody writes a manual for an accident. That distinction matters because an accident gets closed and a policy endures. Cost Seg America has defended studies through more than 125 IRS examinations with zero losses and $0 returned. That record comes from applying the rules the IRS published, with the documentation the IRS described.

Priya's building, with the arithmetic

These figures are illustrative. The appraisal put $170,000 of Priya's $850,000 on land, leaving $680,000 of depreciable basis. Placed in service in March 2025, the 39-year building takes the IRS mid-month table rate for March, 2.033 percent, in year one.

What Priya's CPA had set up. $680,000 straight-line over 39 years: $13,824 of depreciation in 2025 and $17,436 a year after that. Against about $72,000 of net rental income before depreciation, Priya was looking at roughly $58,000 of taxable rental income on top of her pension.

What the fully engineered and accounted cost segregation study found. The engineering supported $177,000 of the basis as shorter-life property, 26 percent, on the low side of the range for a small commercial building: $110,000 examined as 5-year property (removable flooring, the print shop's dedicated 30-amp circuits and compressed-air line, the chiropractor's dedicated plumbing for the treatment-room sinks, decorative millwork) and $67,000 as 15-year land improvements (the parking lot, curbing, two pole lights, the sign base and landscaping). Because the building was acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025, all $177,000 qualified for 100 percent bonus depreciation. The remaining $503,000 stayed on the 39-year schedule.

2025, first yearBasisDeduction
5-year property, 100 percent bonus$110,000$110,000
15-year land improvements, 100 percent bonus$67,000$67,000
39-year shell, mid-month from March, 2.033 percent$503,000$10,226
Total with study$680,000$187,226
Total without study$680,000$13,824
Additional first-year deduction$173,402

At a 37 percent federal rate, $173,402 of additional deduction is worth $64,159 of federal tax. That is the number Priya almost left on the 39-year schedule because she believed the strategy was for bigger players.

The catch in Priya's case

Priya is retired, and her rental loss is passive. A passive loss offsets passive income only, unless an exception applies. Two did.

First, the study's deduction wiped out the $72,000 of rental income from the building itself. That income is passive, so the loss offsets it in full. Second, Priya actively participates in the building, approving tenants and repairs, and her adjusted gross income from her pension and Social Security is under $100,000, so Section 469(i) lets her deduct up to $25,000 of rental loss against her pension income. That allowance phases out between $100,000 and $150,000 of adjusted gross income.

So in 2025 Priya used $97,000 of the $187,226: the rental income plus the $25,000 allowance. The remaining $90,226 is a suspended passive loss. It carries forward and shelters her rental income in 2026 and 2027, and anything left releases in full when she sells. At 37 percent the deduction is worth about $64,200 in total; Priya collects it over three years instead of one. That is still a deduction her nephew does not have, on a building her nephew does not own. One more limit, Section 461(l), caps the business losses an individual can deduct in a year at $313,000 single and $626,000 joint for tax years beginning in 2025, adjusted annually; Priya's numbers stay well under it; an owner with a larger building should check it before counting the refund.

The other catch is recapture. The $177,000 Priya deducted in 2025 is gone from the building's basis. When she sells, that amount is taxed as ordinary income, Section 1245 recapture on the 5-year property and Section 1250 recapture of the excess over straight-line on the land improvements, and the straight-line depreciation on the shell is taxed as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain at up to 25 percent. Priya plans to hold the building until she dies and leave it to her daughter, at which point the basis steps up and the recapture never comes due. If she planned to sell in 2027, the study would be a worse idea.

What an engineered study does that an estimate does not

The published rules tell you a deduction exists. They also tell you what an examiner expects to see behind it. The ATG describes six approaches to allocating a building's cost and prescribes none, but it calls Approach 1, detailed engineering from actual cost records, the most methodical and accurate, and Approach 2, engineering with documented estimates reconciled to actual cost, methodical and reasonably accurate. A fully engineered and accounted study works under Approaches 1 and 2 only. On Priya's building, that meant an engineer identified each component from the drawings and a guided photo and video walkthrough Priya did herself with her phone, counted the circuits and measured the lot, priced each item from documented sources and reconciled the schedule to $680,000.

The result is a schedule Priya's CPA imported line by line and an examiner could trace line by line, signed by credentialed professionals. Cost Seg America defends it for as long as Priya owns the building, with written responses and participation in examiner calls alongside her CPA, no time limit, no hour cap and no additional fee. An estimate from a questionnaire would have handed her a percentage, which is Approach 6 territory, the one the guide says to view with caution.

What the wealthy do differently

If the rules are public, what separates the people who use them from the people who do not? Three habits, none of which require money to start.

They assume the rules apply to them. The ordinary owner assumes the good strategies are for someone bigger. The wealthy start from the opposite assumption and go look. Priya almost did not ask because she figured cost segregation was for the real players. The building did not know that.

They hire someone who has read the manual. Nobody reads the whole ATG for fun. The wealthy pay professionals who have. When people say the rich have advisors, that is what they mean, and it is a service anyone can buy.

They plan before the year ends. The ordinary owner thinks about taxes once a year, in April, after the facts are fixed. The wealthy treat the code as a set of rules to plan around: when to close, when to place in service, when to run the study. The deadline for a study is the filing date including extensions, so the study itself can wait. The purchase date cannot. Acquiring and placing the building in service after January 19, 2025, rather than signing the contract earlier that January, moved the bonus rate on $177,000 of property from 40 percent to 100 percent.

The cost of believing the myth

The myth does damage. It gives you a reason not to look.

Priya's building would have produced $13,824 of depreciation in 2025 and $17,436 a year after that, forever, while $177,000 of 5-year and 15-year property sat inside the 39-year number earning her about $4,500 a year. Every year she believed the loophole story was a year the fast schedule stayed unused. Had she found out in 2029, Form 3115 would have let her catch up, but the money would have arrived four years late and only if she still owned the building.

The most expensive thing Priya almost did was nothing, based on a belief that was false.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming the strategy is only for large properties. Cost Seg America's minimum is $180,000 of depreciable basis after land. Priya's $680,000 cleared it several times over.
  • Assuming silence from the CPA means ineligibility. Most general preparers apply a study rather than originate one. Ask.
  • Reading "big deduction" as "big risk." The risk lives in undocumented studies. The rules themselves are the IRS's own.
  • Expecting a passive loss to wipe out a pension or a salary. It shelters rental income first, then $25,000 if you qualify under Section 469(i), and the rest waits.
  • Buying with a retirement account and expecting depreciation. A building inside an IRA produces no deduction on your return. Priya bought hers in her own name.

When this does not make sense

Under $180,000 of depreciable basis after land, the fee eats too much of the benefit. A sale planned within a couple of years usually means recapture outweighs the time value of the deduction. A passive loss with no rental income, no Section 469(i) allowance and no path to real estate professional or short-term rental treatment is banked for later rather than used now; it is worth something later and nothing in April. And an owner with no taxable income has nothing for the deduction to offset this year.

Frequently asked questions

Is cost segregation a loophole?

No. It applies the recovery periods Congress wrote into Section 168 to the components of a building, following the Tax Court's reasoning in Hospital Corporation of America, and the IRS published a guide describing how examiners review it.

Where can I read the rules myself?

Section 168 of the Internal Revenue Code, Publication 5653, and the Whiteco and Hospital Corporation of America opinions are all online at no cost.

Does this work for one small building?

Yes, above $180,000 of depreciable basis after land. Priya's $850,000 building produced $173,402 of additional first-year deduction in the illustrative example.

I am retired. Can I use the loss?

Against your rental income, yes. Against pension or other income, up to $25,000 a year if you actively participate and your adjusted gross income is under $100,000, phasing out by $150,000. The rest carries forward.

What happens when I sell?

The 5-year property is recaptured at ordinary rates under Section 1245; on the 15-year land improvements, the bonus taken in excess of straight-line is ordinary income under Section 1250, and the straight-line portion, like the building's, is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain at up to 25 percent. A Section 1031 exchange can defer the Section 1245 recapture only to the extent the replacement property has Section 1245 property of its own. A step-up at death eliminates it.

I bought my building years ago. Did I miss it?

No. A look-back study with Form 3115 takes the missed depreciation as a Section 481(a) adjustment on the current return, at the bonus rate that applied when the building was placed in service. No amended returns.

What does the IRS guide say about estimated studies?

Publication 5653 describes a rule-of-thumb approach, Approach 6, that relies on little or no documentation and says examiners should view it with caution. A study that hands you a percentage without a component schedule is in that territory.

Is 100 percent bonus depreciation permanent now?

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act made 100 percent bonus permanent for property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025. Property acquired before that date keeps the phase-down rate set by the year it was placed in service: 80 percent for 2023, 60 percent for 2024, and 40 percent for 2025 placements acquired before January 20, 2025.

Do I need to become a tax expert?

No. You need a provider who has read the manual and applies it under Approach 1 or 2, and a CPA who imports the schedule. The proposal is free and arrives in 24 hours.

Why did my CPA never mention it?

Cost segregation is engineering work. Most CPAs apply the schedule once it exists; few originate the study. Silence is not a verdict.

What to do next

Send Jim Dougherty and his team the address and purchase price of your building, the two facts Priya started with, and you will have a free proposal within 24 hours showing what the published rules produce on your numbers, the method and the flat fee. Call 1-888-365-5023 or email info@costsegamerica.com.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not tax, legal, or accounting advice; consult your CPA or tax advisor about your own facts before acting.

Your Building Already Holds the Deduction. Let's Go Find It.

Use the calculator, see your number, and request your free, no-cost proposal - delivered in 24 hours, with your flat fee quoted upfront and no obligation.

Get My Free Proposal →
Or speak with us directly - 1-888-365-5023