Short answer: A Roth conversion adds taxable income to your return. A cost segregation study on a short-term rental you materially participate in can remove a large share of your taxable income in the same year. When the two land in the same tax year, the loss can absorb most or all of the conversion, so you move retirement dollars into a Roth account at a tax cost far below what the conversion would normally carry. The plan only works if the rental loss is nonpassive, the property is placed in service by December 31, and the conversion is completed by December 31. This article walks through a full example with real arithmetic, the rules that have to be true first, and the mistakes that turn a smart plan into an expensive one.
Nadia sat at her kitchen table in Chattanooga in early November with two numbers she did not like. The first was the balance in her traditional IRA: about $400,000, built over twenty years of rollovers from old employers. The second was the tax bill her advisor had quoted if she converted a slice of it to a Roth this year.
She and her husband Grant file jointly. Nadia earns $150,000 in W-2 wages. Grant runs the business they bought in June: a $1.1 million mountain lodge that sleeps ten, rented by the night, with an average guest stay of about three and a half days. Grant handles the bookings, the guest messages, the turnover schedule, the repairs and the supply runs. He keeps a calendar log, and it shows more than 600 hours since the lodge opened to guests.
The advisor had told Nadia that converting $150,000 would cost her roughly $34,000 in federal tax. That is the price of paying tax now so that the money grows and comes out tax free later. Nadia understood the logic. She still did not want to write the check.
Then Grant mentioned the lodge. "We bought it in June. Don't we get some kind of depreciation on it?"
They did. And once an engineered cost segregation study put real numbers on that depreciation, the conversion that was going to cost $34,363 in federal tax came in at $4,936. Same conversion. Same $150,000. The only thing that changed was the other side of the return.
This post shows you how that works, why it is legal, what has to be true for you to do the same thing, and where people get hurt. Nadia and Grant are an illustration built to show the math, not a client case, and the figures below come from the tax rules for 2026.
Think of your tax return as a bucket with a fixed amount of free space at the bottom. For a married couple filing jointly in 2026, the standard deduction is $32,200, so the first $32,200 of income is taxed at zero. After that, the first $24,800 of taxable income is taxed at 10 percent, and income up to $100,800 is taxed at 12 percent. These thresholds are adjusted annually.
Most high earners have no free space in that bucket. A $150,000 salary fills the zero bracket, the 10 percent bracket and the 12 percent bracket, and spills into the 22 percent bracket before a single conversion dollar arrives. Every dollar you convert lands on top, at 22 or 24 percent.
A large depreciation loss does the opposite. It drains the bucket. It can pull your adjusted gross income down to zero or below, which opens the zero, 10 percent and 12 percent brackets all over again. Conversion income poured into that open space is taxed at those low rates, or not at all.
That is the whole idea. You are not hiding income. You are choosing to recognize retirement income in a year when a legitimate deduction has made your tax rate unusually low. The deduction comes from a real purchase of real property. The conversion is reported in full. Nothing about it is exotic. It just requires that the two events fall in the same calendar year, which is why this article is going up in November rather than April.
When you buy a building, the tax code normally asks you to recover its cost slowly. A short-term rental used by transient guests is generally depreciated as nonresidential real property, and the building portion is depreciated straight line over 39 years. On a lodge placed in service in June, that first-year deduction is a little over one percent of the building basis.
A cost segregation study breaks the purchase into its parts. Land is taken out first, because land is never depreciated. The building is then separated into structural components and the pieces that tax law treats as shorter-life property: certain interior finishes, appliances, furnishings, specialty electrical and plumbing serving equipment, and outdoor improvements such as paving, fencing and landscaping. Property in the shorter-life categories is eligible for 100 percent bonus depreciation under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, when it was acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025. You can read how that provision works in our guide to 100 percent bonus depreciation after OBBBA.
Cost Seg America typically finds $200,000 to $450,000 in additional first-year federal deductions per $1 million of property, with 20 percent to 35 percent of the depreciable basis reclassified. Results depend on the building, its construction and what it contains. Manufacturing and cold storage buildings can exceed that range. A basic residential structure may land at the lower end.
Every study we produce is a fully engineered and accounted cost segregation study, built on Approach 1 and Approach 2 from the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Technique Guide. That matters for this strategy in particular. A conversion is irreversible, and you are sizing it against a deduction number. If the number came from a rough estimate and the deduction later shrinks under audit, your Roth conversion does not shrink with it. You would owe the tax on the conversion and lose the deduction that justified it. For more on how the IRS evaluates a study, see our breakdown of the 13 elements of a quality study.
Here are the facts we will use. Every number below is a round illustration, and it is worth reading slowly because the point of the exercise is the arithmetic.
Without a study, the whole $880,000 is depreciated over 39 years. In June, the first-year deduction is about 1.391 percent of the basis, which is $12,241. The lodge shows a net profit of $11,759.
Their adjusted gross income is $150,000 plus $11,759, which equals $161,759. After the $32,200 standard deduction, taxable income is $129,559 and federal income tax is $17,927. That is the baseline before any conversion.
Now add the $150,000 conversion. Taxable income rises to $279,559, and the tax rises to $52,290. The conversion cost them $34,363, which is about 22.9 percent of the amount converted.
With the study, $237,600 is deducted in the first year through bonus depreciation. The remaining $642,400 of building basis is depreciated at the same June rate, which adds $8,936. Total first-year depreciation is $246,536.
The lodge now shows a loss of $222,536 instead of a profit. Because Grant materially participates and the average stay is under seven days, that loss is nonpassive. It offsets Nadia's wages. We will return to those conditions below because they are the part people get wrong.
Their adjusted gross income becomes $150,000 minus $222,536, which equals negative $72,536. They owe no federal income tax before any conversion, and they have about $72,500 of loss that would carry forward as a net operating loss.
That carryforward is valuable, but it is not the best use of this year. Look at what is still empty. With adjusted gross income at negative $72,536 and a standard deduction of $32,200, they can add $104,736 of conversion income before taxable income becomes positive at all. A conversion of $104,736 costs them nothing in federal income tax.
At the $150,000 conversion, the study cut the conversion tax by $29,427. At $205,536, it cut it by $36,092. In the lowest-tax version of the plan, Nadia and Grant move $104,736 into a Roth with no federal income tax on the conversion.
The deduction produced by the study in this example, about $234,295 more than the straight-line schedule in year one, is not a gift. It is a timing difference. We will cover what comes back later in this article. But for the purpose of a conversion, timing is exactly what you are buying.
This strategy is only as sound as its weakest condition. Check each of these before you do anything on December 30.
Rental real estate is passive by default, and passive losses only offset passive income. A loss that cannot touch your wages cannot absorb a conversion.
There are two common routes around this. The first is the short-term rental exception. If the average period of customer use is seven days or less, the activity is not treated as a rental activity under the passive loss rules, and if you materially participate, the loss is nonpassive. The second is qualifying as a real estate professional, which requires more than 750 hours in real property trades or businesses and more than half of your personal service time in them. Our guide to real estate professional status versus the short-term rental loophole compares them in detail, and there is a separate post on the spouse rules.
For Grant and Nadia, material participation comes from Grant. The most common test is 500 hours in the year. His log has more than 600 hours, and the hours of spouses are counted together for this purpose. Cleaners and a property manager do not count toward that number, and if you hire a management company to run the property, you may fall short. If you suspect you are close to the line, read our post on short-term rentals with management companies before you rely on the loss.
Keep contemporaneous records. A calendar, an email trail and a booking log are far more persuasive than a spreadsheet rebuilt from memory.
Placed in service means ready and available for its intended use, which for a rental generally means it is listed and open to guests. Closing on the property in December while it sits empty does not necessarily get you a deduction that year. If you bought a property and are still renovating, the date matters, and so do the facts around it.
For property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025, 100 percent bonus depreciation applies. The IRS has also issued guidance on determining the acquisition date, covered in our post on Notice 2026-11. If you bought before that cutoff, a different bonus percentage applies and the numbers in this article would not fit your situation.
If you or your family use the property for more than the greater of 14 days or 10 percent of the days it is rented at fair rental value, the tax code treats it as a residence and limits your deductions. Nadia and Grant stayed at the lodge four nights all year. If you are close, read our post on the 14 day rule.
Three more limits apply. Your deductible loss cannot exceed your basis in the activity. The at-risk rules limit losses to the amount you have at risk, though qualified nonrecourse financing secured by real property generally counts. And Section 461(l) caps the business losses you can use against nonbusiness income, such as wages. For 2026 that cap is $512,000 for joint filers and $256,000 for others, and it is adjusted annually. A loss above the cap becomes a net operating loss carryforward, which later offsets only 80 percent of taxable income. Nadia and Grant's loss of $222,536 sits well under the cap. A larger purchase may not. Our post on the 2026 excess business loss limit explains how to test your own number.
Pay the tax with cash from a checking or savings account, not by withholding from the conversion. If you are under 59 and a half, withheld dollars count as an early distribution, and the ten percent additional tax can apply to them. In the zero-tax versions of this plan, you may owe nothing at all. In the $150,000 version, Nadia sends a payment of $4,936, in estimated tax or with the return, from savings.
The conversion half of this plan has its own set of rules, and they are less forgiving than the depreciation half.
The deadline is December 31. A conversion counts for the year in which the money leaves the traditional account. Unlike an IRA contribution, you cannot make a 2026 conversion in April 2027. A custodian also needs time to process the request, so calling on December 29 is a gamble. Start the paperwork by early December.
You cannot reverse it. Since 2018, a Roth conversion cannot be recharacterized. If your deduction shrinks, your income comes in higher than planned, or the market falls the week after you convert, the tax on the conversion is still owed. This is the single biggest reason to size the conversion off a verified study number and not a back-of-the-envelope estimate.
The pro rata rule applies. You cannot choose to convert only the pre-tax dollars or only the after-tax dollars in your IRAs. The tax on a conversion is calculated across all of your traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA balances together. If Nadia had $50,000 of after-tax basis mixed into her $400,000 account, then 12.5 percent of every conversion would come out tax free and 87.5 percent would be taxable. In her case, every dollar is pre-tax, so the full conversion counts as income.
Each conversion starts its own five-year clock. Converted dollars can come out without penalty after five tax years, or for those over 59 and a half. Earnings follow separate rules for qualified distributions. If you are 45 and expect to need this money before retirement, read the rules before you commit.
Watch the income-based thresholds. Conversion income raises your adjusted gross income, and Medicare premium surcharges are based on income from two years earlier. If you are within a couple of years of Medicare, ask your advisor to run the premium effect. In Nadia's case the study drives adjusted gross income so low that the surcharge is not in play.
It is mid-November, and this part is practical. If you are reading this and your rental is already in service, you have about six weeks.
The depreciation does not need to be filed by December 31. You claim it on the return you file next year. But you need to know the approximate size of the deduction before you can size the conversion, and a conversion is irreversible. A good estimate and a verified study are not the same thing.
At Cost Seg America, a standard study takes 20 business days, and rush studies are available for situations like this one. You speak directly with the analyst working on your study, and the process starts with a short call and a document upload. We also give you a same-day or next-morning proposal so you can decide quickly. Property minimums apply: we work on properties with at least $180,000 of depreciable basis after land is removed.
If the study will not be complete before December 31, you have three practical options. First, convert a smaller amount you are confident will be absorbed, using a conservative estimate. Second, convert next year, with this year's study already in hand. Third, skip the conversion and carry the loss forward. None of these is a failure. The goal is to avoid a conversion you cannot afford because you assumed a deduction that never arrived.
A fair article on this topic has to say what the deduction costs in the future, because the future is when you pay it.
When you sell, depreciation you claimed is recaptured. For the shorter-life property, recapture is generally taxed as ordinary income up to the depreciation previously taken. For the building, the part of the gain that comes from straight-line depreciation is taxed at a maximum rate of 25 percent. These are federal rules; this article does not address state taxes.
In practice, many owners never face the full recapture because they hold the property for many years, exchange it under Section 1031 into another property, or hold it until death, when the basis may be adjusted. Those are separate decisions with separate rules. But you should assume, when you plan a conversion, that the deduction you take today is not permanent savings. It is a deferral.
That deferral still does real work in this strategy. You are using this year's deduction against this year's conversion at today's low effective rate. The Roth money then grows with no further tax and, if you meet the requirements, comes out without tax. The depreciation recapture, if it ever arrives, arrives in a different year, at a different rate, on your terms.
Converting before the study is done. A projected deduction that is off by $80,000 can push part of a conversion out of the 12 percent bracket and into the 22 percent bracket or higher. Size the conversion off a completed number.
Assuming a loss is nonpassive because you want it to be. If your hours fall short, the loss is suspended. Your conversion then lands on top of your full salary. We cover what happens to suspended losses in our post on suspended passive losses.
Withholding the tax from the conversion. This shrinks the amount that reaches the Roth and can trigger the ten percent additional tax on the withheld portion for anyone under 59 and a half.
Skipping the CPA. This is a two-part plan, one part on the depreciation side and one on the retirement side. Your CPA needs to see both before December. The study is the technical foundation. The return is yours and your CPA's.
More year-end steps are in our year-end tax planning checklist for short-term rentals. If your lodge, cabin or condo is on the fence between a primary home and a rental, our post on converting a home to a short-term rental walks through that decision.
It can, when the study produces a nonpassive loss in the same tax year as the conversion. The loss lowers your taxable income, and conversion income fills the space it opens in the lower brackets. In the example above, a $150,000 conversion carried a federal tax of $34,363 without a study and $4,936 with one. Your numbers will differ, and the result depends on your income, filing status and the size of your deduction.
Yes. A passive loss can offset only passive income, so it cannot absorb conversion income or wages. You reach nonpassive treatment through the short-term rental exception with material participation, or through real estate professional status. If neither applies, the strategy does not work, even though the depreciation is still allowed and carried forward.
You do not need to file anything by December 31, but you do need to complete the conversion by then. Because a conversion cannot be reversed, you should size it from a completed study or a number you trust. Cost Seg America completes a standard study in 20 business days, with faster rush options available.
No. Recharacterization of conversions was eliminated for tax years after 2017. Once the conversion is done, the income is reported for that year.
Any remaining loss may be carried forward as a net operating loss, subject to the Section 461(l) cap and the 80 percent limit that applies to NOL deductions in later years. The cap is $512,000 for joint filers in 2026 and is adjusted annually. In the example, the loss of $222,536 sits well under the cap, and without any conversion about $72,500 would carry forward.
That depends on your expectations. The carryforward is real, but a net operating loss later offsets only 80 percent of taxable income, and the zero and low brackets you leave unused this year are gone when the year ends. For some owners, carrying the loss forward is the right call, particularly when future rates are expected to be low. It is a modeling question for your CPA.
You do not need to guess at your deduction. Our cost segregation calculator gives you a starting estimate in about a minute, and a conversation with our team turns that estimate into a proposal, often the same day or the next morning. If your property is a short-term rental, start with our guide to the short-term rental tax strategy for 2026 so the rules are fresh before we talk.
Call 1-888-365-5023 or email info@costsegamerica.com. We will tell you plainly whether your property and your timeline fit this plan, and if they do not, we will say that too.
Written by Jim Dougherty and his team at Cost Seg America.
This article is educational and is not tax, legal or investment advice. Federal tax law changes, thresholds are adjusted annually, and every situation depends on its own facts. The couple in the example is an illustration, not a client. Speak with your CPA or tax advisor before making any decision about depreciation or a Roth conversion.
Use the calculator, see your number, and request your free, no-cost proposal - delivered in 24 hours, with your flat fee quoted upfront and no obligation.